It always amazes me when someone says “Dogs are so stupid.” Usually they are referring to a particular dog’s inability to follow their instructions or commands for something the human thinks should be relatively simple. Yet we use dogs to perform many complicated functions in human society from being service and guide dogs for the blind and disabled to performing search and rescue missions to assisting in law enforcement and livestock management. It seems that even though our dogs may be simple minded creatures by our human standards, they are capable of remarkably complex tasks.
So is their “intelligence” a question of our dogs’ ability to perform these complex tasks or our ability to teach them how to perform them? Noted animal trainer Bob Bailey has said that an animal can be trained to do anything of which it is physically capable. The dog world is filled with examples that would support Bailey’s statement. The question isn’t IF our dogs can do something so much as how we communicate and teach them to do it.
Big tasks, small pieces
If someone asked me to design the electrical wiring for a new home, I could probably do it. It’s a complex task but I could break it down and learn each of the components and how to fit them together. The same is true when we teach our dogs something new. To a human, asking your dog to sit and wait while you get something from the car may seem like a simple task but it might be complex for your dog to understand.
Think about it. When I bring a new dog home with me, one of the first things I need to be able to do is keep an eye on her so she doesn’t get into trouble before she learns the “house rules.” Basically, I teach my new dog to follow me everywhere. Even after I teach her to “sit”, asking her to “stay” might be a little strange because I have always asked her to follow me around before that. I’m changing the game and I need to make sure she understands the new rules.
I’ve found that the best way to teach my dogs is in small pieces. It could be teaching a complex chained behaviour like running to the end of a dog walk, stopping, and waiting until released in dog agility or a behaviour like “stay” which has several criteria for where to stay, when, how she should be positioned, and how long to wait. In either case I find that teaching each piece separately is less stressful for my dogs and generally results in faster and more long-lasting learning.
Splitters and lumpers
The human brain has a tremendous capacity for storing patterns and information. Dogs do not share our easy facility with storing and remembering the complex patterns necessary for learning and performing behaviours. The smaller size and development of their brains means they think differently. For example, if you are asked to sit down, you seem to automatically identify an appropriate place to sit, engage the muscles necessary, and perform the posture when asked. So it is often very easy for us to think of a behaviour like “sitting” as one simple task. But our dogs may perceive that behaviour as something more complicated.
Dogs can be very specific creatures. If I teach my puppy to “sit” while we are in the kitchen, she may look at me like I’m crazy if I ask her to “sit” in the living room later that day. The reason for that is she has not generalized the concept of “sit” to know that she should do it in ANY environment and not just the kitchen where she was taught. I have to teach her WHERE to sit in addition to WHAT sit is until she learns to make the general connection of “Sit” anywhere she is asked. I may even need to teach her specifically HOW to sit if I want her to sit in a specific posture or if I want her directly in front of me. So it is important that I split up what I’m asking my dog to do and not just ask for everything at once.
The term Lumping refers to grouping all of the small details into one thing. It is a very human trait. Because of our enlarged cerebral cortex, we tend to group actions into larger patterns and then execute them as one large action. It can be easy for us to misunderstand our dog’s inability to do the same thing since it comes so easily to us. To humans, dogs can sometimes seem ridiculously literal and nitpicky when it comes to behaviours. Why can’t they just do what we ASK them already?
All that “noise”
Even if I’m a clever enough dog trainer to understand that I need to break things down into manageable pieces when teaching my dog, I can still fall victim to another very human habit. Multi-tasking. If I’m training my dog, I may be helping them with a gesture of my hand to give me the behaviour I want. But I may also be encouraging them with verbal praise. I might also be moving around to get to a more comfortable position for me to work. I might have to move a leash or get more treats or even answer the phone. What is my dog supposed to make of all that activity? Which, if any, of those human activities have anything to do with what my dog is supposed to be learning?
Keeping things simple for our dogs while they are learning is not just a matter of teaching small pieces of behaviours that they can understand. It also means keeping the distractions to a minimum so they don’t have to sort through a barrage of sights and sounds to figure out what we are looking for! It can be a struggle to keep our human multi-tasking habits out of the way when teaching our dogs. “Don’t be a distraction” is a lesson I learned over time. Keeping the training process simple, focused, and distraction free just makes learning easier.
Just as the tallest pyramid is built of many smaller blocks of stone, our dogs behaviours are built of individual lessons we teach them. And just like those blocks at the base of the pyramid, many times we can build new and different behaviours on the simple foundation we have built. That is, if we have taken the time to teach those basic lessons well. In my experience, teaching a dog is not about being clever. It is about patience and being sophisticated enough to keep things simple in both how and what we teach our dog.
When you train your dog, do your break things down for them? Do you look at each part of a behaviour and help them understand what you are asking for? Do you keep the training environment as free from distractions as possible? Do you try to keep quiet and not cheerlead or fuss around your dog while you are training? Are you focused on the training and not trying to watch something on the stove or talk to a friend while you are working?
Keeping things simple may not be as simple as it sounds. Our human tendencies and habits can seem much more complex to our dogs than they do to us. It takes effort and focus to keep still enough and simple enough to be the best teachers for our dogs. More importantly, we need to be patient with the training process and take the time we need to learn good training habits and practices and to think through the best ways to teach our dogs.
It can be tempting to look for the most clever new techniques to teach our dogs. But I have found that doing the basics of dog training well is the best way to teach even the most complex behaviours to my dogs. As Leonardo da Vinci once said that “Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication.” The German architect Mies Van Der Rohe put it even more succinctly – “Less is more.”
Until next time, have fun with your dogs.
Be sure to check out the new Canine Nation community on Substack to enjoy more content and join our conversations. You can find the Canine Nation podcast on the Canine Nation website.
Canine Nation ebooks is now available –
You can find them on Amazon, Dogwise, and other online bookstores.
Photo credits –
Setter – Brian Snelson copyright 1986 from Flickr
Terrier – Hans Pama copyright 2010 from Flickr
Retriever – Victor Bayon copyright 2007 from Flickr
Recent Eric Brad CPDT-KA Articles:
- The Dog That Changed My Life
- Keeping Your Dog Informed
- Teaching Your Dog to Not-Behave
- The Simple Complexity of Dog Training
- What The Dog Wants